Heat pump vs. furnace—which is the greater alternative in Canada?

Image by Virrage Pictures from Shutterstock

Ought to your next furnace be a warmth pump? Or, more specifically, should really your up coming furnace and air conditioning device be a heat pump? FYI, it can heat and great your residence, creating it usable all calendar year long. If you’ve by no means listened to of this solution, you are not alone—heat pump awareness and usage is very small. It’s a finest-retained magic formula, considering the technologies has been close to given that 1856.

With all the excitement all over ChatGPT suitable now, I decided to talk to it to make clear what a heat pump is, and it came back again with “a warmth pump is a machine that acts like a magic box, relocating warm or awesome air to make your home relaxed, like a heater in the wintertime and an air conditioner in summer.”

Outside of the straightforward AI facts, right here are some powerful specifics for applying a warmth pump. The “magic” lies in the point that heat pumps are three hundred% more efficient than baseboard heaters and furnaces, and 50% extra productive than AC units. And, unlike most furnaces, they run on electrical power, not fuel (until it’s a hybrid warmth pump). Speaking of gas, a new study identified that warmth pumps are additional successful than gasoline heating, even in cold weather. And here’s one more consideration that could encourage you to transition to a warmth pump quicker than later: some pieces of Canada have banned fossil-gas heating methods in new residences.

That reported, even with their top-quality performance, heat pumps haven’t been adopted in Canada as conveniently as in other parts of the earth. As of 2021, warmth pumps have been the principal supply of room heating in only 6% of Canadian residences. That is much decreased than in Europe, exactly where an estimated 16% of household and business structures used them as of 2022, states Normal Sources Canada (NRCan). And that gap could widen further more with year-more than-yr heat pump sales expanding by virtually forty% in Europe last 12 months (which include equally air-heating and water-heating heat pumps), in comparison to 11% for the rest of the planet, according to the Worldwide Energy Agency.

So, why aren’t Canadians leaping on board, recognizing the probable strength savings of warmth pump remedies? “When speaking about the differences between Canada and Europe, one of the primary drivers that impacts the uptake of residence heating electrification is energy charges,” says Robin Librach, the communications officer for NRCan. The price tag of fuel, electrical energy and organic gasoline have skyrocketed in lots of areas of Europe since Russia invaded Ukraine, so European people are understandably hunting for additional expense-successful techniques to heat and amazing their residences.

Warmth pump demand is heating up

Couple of Canadian households have a warmth pump, but NRCan numbers recommend that the tide might finally be turning. Because the Canada Greener Houses initiative was launched in May perhaps 2021, much more than 47,000 Canadian home proprietors have received grants for warmth pumps. And heat pumps are the most repeated retrofit carried out by those taking part in the method, adopted by home windows and doors, household insulation, air sealing and photo voltaic panels.

At this time, the Canada Greener Homes Grant presents three levels of heat pump rebates, ranging from $2,five hundred to $five,000 relying on the sort of heat pump as effectively as functionality specifications. In Ontario, the place the Canada Greener Homes Grant has been changed by what’s acknowledged as the Property Effectiveness Rebate Furthermore method, warmth pump grants go up to $seven,800.

How considerably does a warmth pump price tag in Canada?

FurnacePrices.ca cites fairly a broad variety of warmth pump price ranges in Canada, from $three,500 to $15,000, “with a basic ductless mini-break up air conditioner method sitting at the lower stop of the rate assortment when a geothermal or floor-supply heat pump arrives with a remarkably greater selling price.” (See below for extra on various warmth pumps.) Components such as the measurement/type of residence, kind of technique, neighborhood set up costs and the manufacturer of solution all aspect into the last warmth pump value.

Sorts of warmth pumps

NRCan’s web site supplies a complete overview of heat pumps and points out the two key styles of household heat pumps: air resource and ground source. Air-source warmth pumps pull warmth from the outside air for the duration of colder months and do the reverse, removing heat air from inside of the household, during the hotter months. The most important change with floor-supply warmth pumps is the real supply. The earth, floor water or equally heat your home in the wintertime and neat it in the summer.

An additional crucial differentiator: how the air is exchanged. A central ducted warmth pump remedy is effective in tandem with the existing ductwork of your household. For residences without the need of ductwork, entrepreneurs can choose for mini break up-procedure heat pumps, which consist of an outside compressor/condenser and 1 or more indoor handling units that are mounted on the wall—much like a space air conditioning unit.

Warmth pumps can also get the job done in condos or apartments, delivered you have a standalone HVAC technique. But if you are element of a entire-constructing program, then the final decision to adopt this technology will appear down to what your rental corporation or making supervisor decides to do. But it is absolutely attainable to put in a warmth pump in a more substantial creating.

Heating and cooling by the quantities

Reflecting Canada’s cooler local weather for a lot of the yr, the broad vast majority of warmth pumps (about seventy five%) bought to day via the Canada Greener Households Grant have been cold-weather air-resource heat pumps (ccASHPs). These models operate perfectly underneath freezing, with current styles developing heat from air as chilly as -25°C.

Which delivers us back again to the grants readily available. Both equally Canada Greener Houses and Household Performance Rebate In addition specify that you very first have to have to get an Energuide home electricity effectiveness evaluation by an strength advisor who is registered with NRCan. And when that evaluation comes again and claims your household qualifies for a warmth pump retrofit, your system should be put in by a licensed and experienced expert. So, no dwelling handyman installs—no make a difference how helpful you come about to be.

Your installation firm will operate with you to recognize what sort of system makes the most sense, no matter whether ground or air resource, ducted or ductless. And in the end, the dollar benefit of the heat pump rebate will count on what variety of technique you have mounted, which have to also fulfill proscribed functionality requirements.

Qualifying for the Canada Greener Homes Grant

For your warmth pump to qualify for the Canada Greener Households grant of $2,500, it ought to be an Power Star–certified air-source heat pump (so not thought of “cold air”) capable of making 12,000 BTUs for every hour when outside temperatures are as low as eight.3°C. And from a cooling standpoint, the unit should satisfy a Seasonal Electrical power Efficiency Rating (SEER) equal to or larger than 15.two. (SEER rankings assortment from 13 to thirty.)

To enable you grasp what SEER signifies, here’s how the Mitsubishi Electric web-site describes it: “SEER is the miles for every gallon of HVAC and signifies how substantially electricity is needed to run a unit at whole capacity in the course of a given period of time.” (As a substitute of miles for every gallon, imagine kilometres for each litre, listed here in Canada.) So, the greater the SEER, the fewer electrical energy necessary to run the unit. And generally, the higher the SEER, the much more pricey the warmth pump.

Mini or multi-split cold-climate air-supply heat pumps also qualify for a $2,500 grant. Vitality Star air-supply heat pumps for centrally ducted units or break up techniques with three or additional air source retailers are suitable for a $4,000 rebate. And chilly-weather air-sourceheat pumps for central or ductless with 3 or far more stores will get you $five,000.

All of these systems need to also comply with the minimum amount heating and cooling effectiveness figures pointed out previously mentioned. All solutions and devices have to be bought in Canada.

Take note that some of these grants are not available for people of Nova Scotia or Quebec, so it is best to talk to with your nearby heat pump installer to understand about your choices. Or if you want to do some original research, NRCan itemizes the different warmth pump grants explained over (which include exclusions). If you live in Ontario, test out the Enbridge Fuel webpage focused to the Dwelling Efficiency Rebate In addition program (a partnership concerning NRCan and Enbridge). In Nova Scotia, go to Effectiveness Nova Scotia, and in Quebec, the Rénoclimat application.

Is a warmth pump appropriate for your residence?

Regardless of whether or not you should really set up a heat pump count on a lot of variables, including how major your power bills are, the dimensions and strength effectiveness of your property and, at minimum for some, no matter whether or not you want to decrease your own carbon footprint.

Canadians also have to have to prevail over the idea that warmth pumps will not perform through wintertime months. As noticed by NRCan’s Librach, “Contrary to typical misconceptions, electric heat pumps are a demonstrated technological know-how in chilly climates,” and the latest prototypes are capable of making heat from air as cold as -31°C.

Nevertheless a different perceived barrier is price. But Librach can help to place this into point of view: “Heat pumps can price tag extra up entrance than standard heating systems, but their higher efficiency can pay off in the very long run, specially when thinking of obtainable incentives.” For many home proprietors, Librach provides, the price of the grant they obtain could represent fifteen% to twenty five% of their mounted prices.

Then all over again, the all round effectiveness of a heat pump—or any heating or cooling system—also depends on how nicely insulated and sealed the property is. An Energuide audit will each itemize and prioritize the power updates you must contemplate receiving completed. Librach recommends that household owners take an “envelope-initial approach” that aids to lessen heat (and cooling) decline and lowers the warmth (and cooling) load of a dwelling.

If your home is previously perfectly insulated and you want to substitute your current furnace or AC unit, putting in a warmth pump could establish to be your greatest solution. Take into account finding one—heat pumps are below to continue to be, and you are going to enjoy obtaining a cleaner, much more vitality-successful way to heat and cool your property.

Additional about household renovations:

• How significantly are solar panels in Canada?
• Multigenerational Residence Renovation Tax Credit history: What is it and do you qualify?
• Are home renovations tax deductible in Canada?
• What expenses can you deduct when renovating a rental property?
• What you have to have to know before setting up a dwelling renovation